When an Internet Love Triangle Goes Horribly Wrong (and Freaktastic)

Love Triangle

Reason 798 why the Internet creeps me out: (which is even weirder than reason 797: the government probably reading everything I’ve ever put on here), people not being who they say they are online.

Wired Magazine recently featured a story that is the mother of all mistaken Internet identity tales, and reads like some kind of psychotic Lifetime movie of the week. Stay with me now.

Thomas Montgomery, a 45-year-old husband of 16 years and father of two teenage girls was living a pretty uneventful life in upstate New York. After spending 12 years at the same boring job, something inside Montgomery must have snapped, causing the man to live a monotonous life no more—at least in cyberspace. Deciding to log onto the game and chat site Pogo.com as a “19-year-old marine” named Tommy who was getting ready to ship out to Iraq, stood 6 feet tall, and had a “9 inch dick”, Montgomery set out to live a double life.

And live it he did, once he began talking to a 16-year-old girl from Virginia named Jessi. Jessi fell in love with Montgomery’s Tommy, talking to him for hours at night and sending him G-strings in the mail.

Sometimes, just to shake things up, Montgomery would pretend to be Tommy’s father, admonishing Jessi for making mistakes in the relationship.

Eight months after instant messaging every day and speaking on the phone, Tommy proposed to Jessi. Jessi accepted. In a bizarre New Year’s Eve resolution, Montgomery wrote “On January 2, 2006, Tom Montgomery (46 years old) ceases to exist and is replaced by an 18-year-old battle-scarred marine”.

But the only thing that really happened was Montgomery’s wife finding his secret stash of G-strings and realizing her husband was cyber cheating with a girl as old as his daughter. Being a mother, and a sane individual, Montgomery’s wife contacted Jessi and let her know Tommy didn’t exist.

Distraught, Jessi contacted a friend of Montgomery’s who also frequented Pogo.com, 22-year-old Brian Barrett, and asked him if Tommy was indeed a fake. Barret told her he was. A disappointed Jessi began messaging Barret in place of Tommy, and the two began their own online relationship.

A relationship Montgomery found out about. A relationship that pissed the delusional father of two off so much he (allegedly) followed Barret to work and shot him three times.

When Jessi was contacted about the crime, her mother answered for her, saying her daughter wasn’t around. But as cops pushed, they noticed something odd about Jessi’s mother. She acted strangely, nervous, like she knew something.

Turns out, Jessi’s mom, was Jessi.

The icing on this freaking weird cake, Jessi didn’t exist at all. Jessi was really a housewife named Mary, using her daughter’s profile.

I couldn’t make this shit up if I tried.

…And I don’t think I’d ever want to.

11 Comments on "When an Internet Love Triangle Goes Horribly Wrong (and Freaktastic)"

  1. Andrew - University of Michigan says:
    Thu, 23rd Aug 200712:22 pm 

    THAT is one of the crazier things I’ve ever heard

  2. jane says:
    Thu, 23rd Aug 20073:13 pm 

    WOAH- this is whack. Great story.

  3. Ashley says:
    Fri, 24th Aug 20073:15 am 

    Wow. I agree with Jane – that is whack. So totally and completely ridiculous.

  4. Don says:
    Fri, 24th Aug 20078:39 am 

    Whoever made up this story is equally whacked.

  5. betty says:
    Fri, 24th Aug 20079:57 am 

    I have a comment it is so easy. For anyone to start a relationship on line. Because yes you can become anyone. You don’t need to be good looking. Or even give your name nor age. Some people do it. Probably because they are lonely. I can relate with some of you. But I’m not going to put myself in danger. You better wise up fast. Or you just might end up the same way. Please becareful. Don’t be taken by someone. Who just want to harm you. Yes you can mingal with people. But don’t take risks. Get out while you still have time.

  6. mary says:
    Fri, 24th Aug 200710:30 am 

    it is unbeliveabe that adults have so little to their lives that they create such messess all in the name of ?? excitement. There needs to be policing on the internet because adults can’t seem to manage it.

  7. steph says:
    Wed, 31st Oct 200712:41 pm 

    sadly this story is completely true… i *lived* across the street from the guy before he was arrested n now hes taken away his guilty plea and going to trial in november.. while the woman involved is at no fault in the eyes of the law however, she deserves to be locked up just as much as he does… crazy stuff goin on these days..

  8. JLS says:
    Fri, 18th Apr 20082:56 pm 

    I play on pogo a LOT, there are some very nice, normal people on there, but there are all kinds of whackos too, that lie about who and what they are. One woman got obsessed with a very good looking man on there who was bisexual, and when he wasn’t interested in her, she made a new identity as a gay man and approached him that way. Like the rest of the internet, you just don’t know who is on the other end of the keyboard.

  9. Koley says:
    Fri, 2nd May 20089:03 pm 

    I’m a pogo’er too… and yes, there are wackos on there. Luckily the only real encounter I’ve had with a pogo wacko was cut short. By me calling him out on some little inconsistency and then he decided that I was too good for him. :)

  10. Koley says:
    Fri, 2nd May 20089:03 pm 

    Oh, and this was the most hilarious thing I have read ALL day!!!

  11. koley hater says:
    Sat, 17th Jan 200912:23 pm 

    koley you asshole, im related to the boy murdered in this story and your ignorance by saying this is “hilarious” makes me wish something like this happens to you so i can laugh back. how are you gonna even get to a point where you feel too good for someone on pogo? are you kidding. its a game site you freak. go to match.com or ashleymadison.com if you wanna relationship. not some nerd infested pogo site. says a lot about you. cant wait till i hear of a koley travesty…cant f’n wait u ignorant piece of sh*t

Tell us what you're thinking...




COVER STORY

Burnt To a Crisp? Read On… Burnt To a Crisp? Read On…

Now that a lot of us hold weekly office jobs, it makes perfect sense that we want... 

Duke It Out: Forgive a Cheater? Duke It Out: Forgive a Cheater?

[It's pretty obvious that the average CollegeCandy reader has some very strong opinions.... 

The Doctor Is In: Which Birth Control Is Best For Me? The Doctor Is In: Which Birth Control Is Best For Me?

Talking sex with your doctor isn’t always easy. Whether you are afraid she or... 

Read More Posts From This Category

HAHA

WTF Friday: The Unisex Romper WTF Friday: The Unisex Romper

I love the way rompers look (on other people). I love penises (on other…male…people). I... 

Bibs, Binkies and Other Things We Wish They Made in Our Size Bibs, Binkies and Other Things We Wish They Made in Our Size

I am a notorious people watcher and window shopper.  Whenever I’m walking... 

Five Beach Essentials You Never Knew You Needed (Until Now!) Five Beach Essentials You Never Knew You Needed (Until Now!)

The season of sun is finally here, and that means three things: sand, water, and... 

Read More Posts From This Category
Overheard: Boink!

Overheard: Boink!

(Two girls, at a sobriety checkpoint.)
Officer: Where are you girls off to?
Girl 1: Nowhere. Just carrying tons of booze around in our car for no reason.
Officer: That’s not funny, you know.
Girl 1: Sorry, Officer.