Shirtless and SweatyMan: 5 Ways Superhero Movies Would Be Different if a Chick Wrote Them
May 16, 2008 Posted in Buzz, Other Stories
I like superhero movies. They’re rad. Growing up in the rural North East, there wasn’t much to do once the sun went down, and so instead of huffing paint thinner in the backyard like our neighbors, my brother and I turned to comics. X-Men, Batman, Spiderman, Aliens…and all the 701 offshoots of each. Many hours of my childhood were spent sitting in a Ninja Turtle tent in my brother’s room, passing the newest issue of X Force and a box of Hostess cupcakes back and forth with him.
I’ve seen the X-man movies, watched every single Spiderman (even though I have this huge issue with Kristin Dunst), drooled over Christian Bale as Batman, and recently had the ultimate pleasure of watching Iron Man – and Robert Downy Jr. – kick ass on the big screen.
[Okay, slight tangent: can we talk about the scene where RDJr. is in the cave, and he’s all mad and sweaty and dirty and hammering STEEL? Lord. Pass the HOTsauce please]
I’ve loved all of these movies. They were great fun. But being a writer, and ALSO being a chick, I’ve noticed a really sh*tty trend: in almost all of these films, women are pretty useless.
Since X-Men is more of an ensemble movie, let’s put that aside and focus on Spiderman, Batman, and Iron Man. Besides standing and looking sleek and serious, most of the “leading ladies” in these movies don’t have much to do except walk around indignity until they somehow get into trouble and force the hero to make a big detour and save their ass. Throw in a few one-liners and 4-inch heels and there you have it: a pretty useless pretty face.
I’m not here to write a thesis on why this is, since I already basically know the answer, which is two fold: A) men mostly write comic books and B) men mostly write superhero movies. What I’m here to do is give you the Top 5 Ways a Superhero Movie Would Be Different If A Chick Wrote It:
5) More Dialogues About Feelings
Have you ever noticed how short these movies are on emoting and talking it out? Instead of picking apart their complicated feelings about their love interest or crappy past, superheroes just strap on some metal and latex and set sh*t on fire. If a chick wrote a superhero movie, sh*t would still get set on fire, but the hero would also sit down with his leading lady and explain to her just WHY he’s so brooding and hard to connect with (and feels the need to set sh*t on fire).
4) A Change of Wardrobe: Banning the 4-inch Heel
I don’t know about you, but the last thing I feel like doing in 4-inch heels is walking quickly, let alone running down the street. No wonder women in superhero movies get captured all the time; how are you supposed to get anywhere with your feet encased in stripper shoes?
3) Less Technical Babble
Look, Hollywood screenwriters, you’re not fooling anyone. We all know all that techno mumbo jumbo A) doesn’t exist and B) is only there to make you and every other guy in the theater feel cool. You’re making up words, shoving a ton of them in a paragraph, and telling Robert Downy Jr. to make them sound believable. Lucky for you, he can do that, but next time? Why not fill that space with a little monologue that lets us see the heart behind the mask? Or better yet, just spend those two minutes on the hero stripping in front of a mirror. Which brings me to number 2…
2) More Naked Guy Action
Since these movies are usually written by a dude (or 4, as the case was in Iron Man. Seriously? Four?! There was one guy who just came up with fake technical bullsh*t, wasn’t there?), no one really thinks about the amount of hot male bod action, but let me tell you, if a chick was writing it, you BEST BELIEVE there’d be shirtless scenes galore. Raise your hand if you’d like to watch Christian Bale walk around the batcave in boxer briefs, or Robert Downy Jr. wax his suit in tighty-whities. Where are our shower scenes?! Where’s the sweaty work out montages? If I wrote one of these superhero films, I’d make a point of having my lead character ripped and sweaty and shirtless for at least 78% of the film.
1) Better Female Roles (for F*ck’s Sake)
No more annoying romantic interests who exist purely because moviegoers need a little T and A in every film. No more nosey news reporters who shove their nosey noses where they obviously shouldn’t go and end up being bait for the bad guy. It’s time for women to have good dialogue, costumes more complicated than a tight pencil skirt and the aforementioned hooker heels, and a reason for being in the damn movie in the first place.
I’ve got some ideas. Hollywood, have your peeps call me, alright?
Tell us what you're thinking...
















How to Screw Up the First Date
Why Jennifer Lawrence is the Coolest Actress Ever
Men in Black Take on The Avengers
Jeopardy Without Trebek?!
Stop Sleeping With Your Ex!





Natalie says:
Fri, 16th May 20087:11 am
I think one of the best examples of the "useful" woman in a movie like this is Transformers. Not quite a superhero movie, but close enough. The female lead has a past, can fix cars, actually helps out in the end instead of being bait, and let's face it…she's totally hot.
J - NYU says:
Fri, 16th May 20087:25 am
Natalie, I agree.
Wouldn't Meghan Fox make the BEST superheroine?!
Melissa says:
Fri, 16th May 20087:27 am
I'm gonna fight you all for RDJ!!! I lust him forever.
Mal says:
Fri, 16th May 20087:45 am
In iron man though, the girl at the end is the one who has to push the button that destroys everything… that helps a lot doesnt it? haha i dunno. i do agree though, that there are a lot of hero movies where girls have stupid roles.
JR says:
Fri, 16th May 20081:14 pm
Well it was the first Iron man, they didn't really showed us more about pepper potts, but she has a role in the next movie with the Avengers (see end of Iron man), but yeah the superhero movies lack many substancial superheroines
Keith says:
Fri, 23rd May 20088:47 pm
Yeah, but traditionally in source material for the movies you listed, the women still didn't have much to do. They don't have the superpowers or have the enhancements or have all the fight training. Storm had something to do in X-Men, Kitty did eventually, Mystique did, Rouge shouldn't have been in the films at all, now once we get She-Hulk, Runaways, Black Widow, Supergirl, Wonder Woman. It'll be a different story, but only for those characters. It's not that the women are useless because of the writers, it's just the characters aren't meant to be useful in that manner.