Hofstra Student Lies About Being Raped

hofstra

Innocent and happy to be heading home.

This past Monday, while most of us were snoozing through lectures, four Hofstra students were arrested, slapped with a “rapist label” and thrown in a jail cell facing up to 25 years for gang raping a  freshman.

The next day my mom called me distraught.

“Please lock all your doors.”
“Do not go home alone or stay out really late.”
“If a guy is following you or you feel at all uncomfortable, call the police.”

In an instant all college guys were DANGER.

While most of us tend to bop around in our (seemingly) safe, little campus bubbles, this situation forced me to wake up and realize that this is a valid and substantiated fear. College girls all over the country have been taken advantage of on campus, from harassment to rape. This is a real concern for all of us.

Which is why this Hofstra freshman’s story was taken so seriously.
Too bad she made the whole thing up.

Yep, she admitted to officials last night that the sex had been consensual.

When I heard, I (as I’m sure most people were) was disgusted. Whenever this kind of case arises, the woman is always given the benefit of the doubt. These cases are not taken lightly at all, and while our justice system claims to base itself on the principle “innocent until proven guilty,” the minute a woman points the Rape finger at a man, he is done for.

The fact that this girl turned a very real danger into a joke is taking the validity away from future victims who come forward about being raped. Now instead of dealing with the problem as a legitimate one, victims are going to be second-guessed. “Was she really raped, or did she just wake up and decide her one night stand was not such a good idea?”

Being doubted or suspected of lying could continue to silence girls who are raped, which leaves the men who take advantage of them out there unpunished, able to take advantage of another girl.

And then there are the poor guys. Yes, they have been vindicated, but how can they simply return to their normal lives? They just spent three days in a jail cell with their picture plastered across the news as the latest poster boys of rape. They lost their jobs, they lost respect and now everything is supposed to go back to normal?

This girl is now being “investigated,” why, I do not know. If anything, she needs to be punished and ASAP. Did they “investigate” these four guys when she accused them? No, they threw them in a jail cell. Why is she still being given the benefit of the doubt?

Rape should not be taken lightly – it is not a term that should just be thrown around – and I am disgusted that this student, a woman, doesn’t agree.


25 Comments on "Hofstra Student Lies About Being Raped"

  1. Erich says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20092:00 pm 

    This happens all the time in the military too. Its a complete sham that the guys dont get the benefits of the doubt. Just like those guys from Duke a few years back. The police just automatically believe that the guy is guilty and the girl is innocent and just think those are our tax payer dollars be used for the best according to the system.

  2. Casey says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20092:04 pm 

    I am also disgusted by this. As a woman who has been raped, situations like this infuriate me. The same thing happened at my high school when I was a senior. A guy and girl were smoking pot in the teachers bathroom (first mistake) and when they walked out of the bathroom they realized there was a camera outside that saw the whole thing. The girl was already on behavior contract so as not to get out of school she went straight to the office and told authorities that the boy, a star football player, had raped her. He spent 2 weeks in prison, got kicked off the football team, lost his scholarship, and his early acceptance to college. The girl finally admitted that she made it up so she wouldn’t get in trouble.

    I was raped by my, then, boyfriend when I was 14, and sexually molested by his father. The first time my boyfriend raped me he stabbed me (I still have the scar) and told me if I told anyone he would do worse. When I finally went to the authorities they told me there was nothing they could do since I didn’t have any proof and too many girls make up stories about being raped.

    It disgusts me that girls do shit like this. Do they have no integrity? If you make a mistake and realize “oops, maybe I didn’t want to have sex with him” take some fucking responsibility for your actions! It’s not rape because you decide LATER that you didn’t want to do it. Maybe you should have thought about it a little harder BEFORE you did it.

  3. bunny says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20093:08 pm 

    Casey, you’ve got a story for almost every article on here.

  4. Casey says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20093:30 pm 

    Yeah, I realized that the other day. I’ve just experienced a lot in 22 years.

  5. Dia says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20094:43 pm 

    aww man now when they apply for jobs they will have to say theyve been to jail, so lame and there will still be people who dont completely trust them anymore, just last week at my school a girl claimed rape but a few days later we found out she made it up

  6. Bunny says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20095:28 pm 

    That sucks Casey. Like, really sucks. Some people just don’t get a fair deal in life :/

  7. Karin says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20095:59 pm 

    Okay, this may not make a lot of sense at first, but bear with me. This collegecandy post upsets me for different reasons than it seems to upset everyone else.

    Last semester, as a sophomore, I was sexually assaulted. It was something that wasn’t my fault but there were things I could have done to prevent it: not drink, not allow the guy (who I just met, but my female friend told me he was a good guy and you assume he is because he is her best friend) to walk me home. But I did. I was able to escape before it could get worse, and I called my best male friend and the friend who he was visiting. When they came, my male friend could automatically tell something wasn’t right but my female friend didn’t get why I was hysterically crying. The male friend took me back to his room and surrounded me with people to talk. The next few weeks was spent with counselors, deans, and friends. It was rough. Somewhere along it all though, the administration and even my own friends started to have me almost believe that it was consensual. But it wasn’t! For awhile, I believed that I was equally to blame, and I believe that I did something wrong.

    I believe that this girl, if she felt something wrong happen, we should believe something wrong happen. If the next day she’s saying “she made it all up” we should wonder why did her story change? and not be preaching about how rape is serious and it sucks that people lie about it. The way our society works is the women has always misunderstood, lying, or wrong.

    I don’t know her, so I don’t know the full story, but let’s give her some sympathy too. Being there, I know how rough it can get.

  8. Melissa says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20096:51 pm 

    It infuriates me that women make up rape cases. It’s even worse when they point the finger at a minority, wasting time and money and making people afraid for no good reason, looking for a person that doesn’t even exist, or ruining someone else’s life because they can’t own up to their own mistake. This has happened many times at my own university, and the most horrible thing of all is now when I get an email or a notice about a crime, I dismiss it because 9 out of the last 10 cases, it was a hoax.

  9. Casey says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20097:23 pm 

    Karin, I understand your frustration, and I’m sure that does happen a lot of the time, but truth be told, there are dishonest people in this world, TONS of them. And they will lie, cheat, and ruin peoples lives to serve their own sick purpose (like not getting in trouble for something, or making themselves feel better about a mistake). It sucks and makes it extremely difficult to know if someone is lying or not. But that’s why everyone else feels the frustration they do, maybe not particularly because of this incident, but many other similar ones that have occurred.

  10. Casey says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20097:40 pm 

    Bunny, ever since I was little whenever I said, “that’s not fair!” my mom would always say, “where on your birth certificate does it say that life will be fair?” No one really has a fair life, we all have our share of issues, some just get hit harder than others, or in worse ways. Despite all the crap that I’ve been through I’m still thankful that it’s not as bad as it could be. And I take my experiences and am stronger because of them.

    Thanks though, for the compassion.

    Also when I was about 3, one day my dad said “life stinks” to which I replied, “I’ve never smelled it, but I’m sure it does”. Well, now I have smelled it, and it in fact does stink, but I’ve learned to hold my nose.

  11. B says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20098:17 pm 

    Casey- That has got to be one of the worst things I have ever heard. I’m sorry you had to go through it, but props to you for putting it out there.

    As for the girl who made this crap up, she should be imprisoned just like those boys were, and she should have to register as a sex offender when she gets out. She should also be sued for defamation of character, lost wages, and emotional distress. Bitches like her make me SICK.

    As for the poster who said why did she point the finger at a minority….? They never released her identity, that I know of, so for all you or I know, she may be the same ethnicity.

    By the way- even though these boys were wrongly accused, they were still wrong to get involved with this girl- 5 on 1 is not what I would call socially acceptable. In most cases I’d be appalled that they filmed this, but in this case, it’s certainly good they did.

  12. Bunny says:
    Thu, 17th Sep 20099:37 pm 

    @Casey: What a great view on life. You’ve a real sweet outlook.

  13. Becca- Clarion University says:
    Fri, 18th Sep 200910:29 am 

    When I was 16, I was a girl who was held down, and the guy I was with decided to have sex with me until I agreed. For years I thought it was my fault, that I should’ve done more to stop him. I’ve hated myself everyday for not doing something about it…and now, this woman has the audacity to potentially ruin any chance for a woman who *can* do something about it… I have to say I’m disgusted by this. And it breaks my heart a little…

  14. Erica says:
    Fri, 18th Sep 20098:58 pm 

    Casey- Seek help for your issues please. Your life is so fucked up I can’t believe how fucked up in the head you are. Please seek treatment for all of your issues. If not, you will end up dead in a gutter somewhere. You continue to date terrible men who will treat you like shit, beat you, and will sexually abuse you if you don’t seek treatment. You have severe issues from your childhood that have set you down a road of destruction. Seek help. Thank you for seeking help. I am glad I could help you.

  15. criolle says:
    Sat, 19th Sep 200911:47 am 

    There is already has more evidence of an actual crime committed by her than she had against the four men that were incarcerated.
    Yet no charges have been filed against HER.
    We’re hesitating to imperil the future of a woman simply for committing a possible felony that led to the false imprisonment and public humiliation of four innocent men.
    Where was the hesitation when THEIR futures were at stake?
    HER name is being withheld by the press because of “rape shield” laws. No such courtesy was granted to the four men. Nor was such courtesy granted to the three involved in the infamous Duke case.

    Disgusting sexism.

  16. molly says:
    Sun, 20th Sep 20094:07 pm 

    My good friend was just convicted of a rape he did not commit, and it’s ruined his whole life. He was thrown out of the marines, his life-long goal, and he is on a sex offender list for the next 20 years. He was a virgin, and a gentleman. The girl got embarrassed when her friends made fun of her for sleeping with someone so “nerdy” or whatever, so she called rape.
    It makes me so sick.

    p.s….erica, please kindly shut the hell up. thanks! I doubt casey feels you’ve “helped” her one iota. :)

  17. Hofstra Girl says:
    Sun, 20th Sep 20094:37 pm 

    well what REALLY is annoying me and most of my friends right now is the news stations are everywhere on campus. all just trying to get any small news to give my school a bad name all because of that incident. people are over analyzing everything from a guy greeting a girl hello with a kiss on the cheek. the news people are also going around asking indecent questions to the people who work here and students just to get anything out of it.

  18. Leonard Nicodemus III says:
    Mon, 21st Sep 20093:53 am 

    That girl should get at least 10 years in the can, if not more.

  19. kiki says:
    Thu, 24th Sep 20095:22 pm 

    i think she was threaten, why on earth would she say she was gang raped if she wasn’t?
    They should have had done a test to verify if she was in fact raped or not, that’s the only way to know for sure.

  20. cpd says:
    Wed, 30th Sep 20094:13 pm 

    Something similar happened to me a few years back on campus.. Me and a girl were both drunk.. we had sex(she happened to be a virgin). i walked her back to her room. The next day she said it was rape.. The story would of got out of control but thank god my room mate happened to walk in when it happened and saw her participating more than i was be cause i laying down… To this day im still bothered and yes im a minority and she not.. I figured she was probably embarrassed b.c she was a virgin and thought i would tell the whole school how i popped her cherry so she came up with this horrible story that could have/would have killed my future

  21. Casey says:
    Wed, 30th Sep 20094:17 pm 

    cpd, it’s great to have a male perspective on this issue. Thank you for sharing! and I’m sorry that happened to you. :( Luckily you had a witness.

  22. mollination says:
    Sat, 17th Oct 20093:39 pm 

    There needs to be a hard and fast law for women who claim rape. Aren’t there laws about lying to the authorities and wasting man-power/tax dollars?

  23. Andrew says:
    Sat, 24th Oct 200911:00 pm 

    rape is being trivialized. and the males who are being falsely accused of rape are themselves, in a sense, being raped. in the same way being raped leaves a lasting effect on a woman, being falsely accused of raping someone does as well. the law of course, has always given females the benefit of the doubt, in all sorts of cases besides rape cases. it’s sad that in this day and age men and women are not equal in the eyes of the law. and on top of that, things like this cause society to continue to treat the female gender as victims, thus perpetuating sexism against women.

  24. Doug says:
    Mon, 4th Jan 20101:40 pm 

    False rape accusations should be prosected, and receive serious sentences. It should be a felony. It has serious consequences for the accused men. Very serious ones. The least of it is the few days jail before getting bailed out if they do. It’s the public shaming with many people never quite believing that they didn’t do it “or something close and very aggressive / bad”. (The Hofstra guys merely had consensual group sex with her, and then she bumped into her boyfriend in stairwell right after while she was still reeking and looking like heavy sex, so she made up the rape alabi.

    I don’t think men should be arrested for rape on a mere he said / she said before there’s an extensive police investigation. And good evidence for the accusor’s accusation. The feminist lie that women don’t lie about rape is just that, a lie. They do a lot, particular in the current campus climate on many campuses.

Tell us what you're thinking...




COVER STORY

21 Things I Learned in My 21st Year 21 Things I Learned in My 21st Year

#9: Reading for pleasure is magical. Make time for it! Just last February, I was... 

Take Action to End Violence Against Women Take Action to End Violence Against Women

One of the most important issues we are facing today is violence against women. Based... 

The Sober One The Sober One

It took until the middle of my junior year of college, but I finally went to my first... 

Read More Posts From This Category

HAHA

Show Yourself Some Love This Valentine’s Day Show Yourself Some Love This Valentine’s Day

For us single girls, Valentine’s Day can seriously suck. Even if you love... 

Single. On Valentine’s Day Single. On Valentine’s Day

So I don’t know if you’ve heard, but Valentine’s Day is coming up. Yes, as... 

The CC Weekly Weigh In: Significant Jerks The CC Weekly Weigh In: Significant Jerks

I'd rather spend my V-day crying into a bowl of noodles than have to hang out... 

Read More Posts From This Category