I’m Torn: Making The First Move

girl flirtingBoys. What a confusing subject. More confusing than my European History class and Biological Bases of Behavior class combined, and they’re tough enough alone as it is. You think they feel one way and it turns out they feel the exact opposite; sometimes good, other times bad. If they’re were an award on Most Mixed Messages Sent In One Night, boys would definitely take the cake. And the trophy. And then celebrate with a beer bong.

Right now there’s this guy I kind of have a crush on but I have no idea what he’s thinking so I’m not sure what to do. My sorority and his fraternity always have mixers together, and no matter whom our respective dates are we always end up dancing together in the end. At our last function we hooked up and exchanged numbers, but then, thanks to Swine Flu and a class field trip (yeah, we still have those), I couldn’t see him for weeks. We’ve been doin’ a bit of flirxting (that’s text flirting…start using it) but nothing real has happened so far. I know some people think ladies should suck it up and make a move, but I tend to hang out in the guys-always-make-the-first-move corner.

And he’s not making one. Should I?
I’m torn.

Love It:
If I do ask him out on a date and he says yes, then that would be a definite step in the right direction and I would know for certain that he was crushin’ on me too. And if says no, then at least I know and can move on. Because right now I’m totally confused and stuck in the middle (and over-analyzing his every text), and that’s never a good feeling.

I’ve heard some guys even like when girls make the first move, because it shows that they’re interested and have the confidence to show their true feelings. I don’t know how many guys this applies to, but it would be great if they could tell us if they liked it or not. That might be wishing for too much though.

Loathe It:
If I don’t do anything, then I’m just like any other girl. But that may be a good thing too, because I don’t want to seem too forward or too aggressive, because those traits are even worse than being too shy. I’ve never made the first move in the past, so I’m used to that road and am comfortable taking it. I like this way better because it forces the guy to take action and makes them show you how they feel so you know if they feel the same way or not.

And then there’s the whole “Not making an ass of myself,” which is always good. The last thing I want is to tell this guy that I wanna makeout some more and have him tell me he’s actually semi-dating some other girl.

So what do you think? Would you ever make the first move? Is it worth it?

21 Comments on "I’m Torn: Making The First Move"

  1. T says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20091:30 pm 

    Unfortunately, i am in this same predicament.

  2. Lauren - University of Michigan says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20091:33 pm 

    Suck it up and go for it! Not knowing is the worst part. What is the worst thing that could happen? You tell him you like ihm and he says he doesn’t like you back? Fine. That will sting for 2 minutes, but at least you won’t waste your time on him anymore.

    And it seems like he IS into you but he’s just too much of a wimp to really make the grand gesture. I think you’re good to go ahead and make the first move. Doesn’t seem like he’ll mind at all.

  3. Eleanor says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20091:44 pm 

    Really, you think if he liked you enough to ever ask you out, that he would suddenly stop liking you because you seem too “forward”? If that is enough to turn around his feelings for you, then he didn’t like you all that much. As for all the other situations, not asking is just prolonging the agony – either prolonging the time it takes to get something more serious happening, or prolonging the time it takes to find out that he doesn’t like you.

    Even if you are rejected, you’ll get over it. And you’ll feel so proud of yourself, like a real bad-ass! It’s not making a fool of yourself – even if you are rejected, it is impressive to people, including him most of the time, that you had the the courage to do it. And I’m saying this as someone who has asked out a couple guys and been rejected each time. So as someone who has had the worst possible luck with it, I am assuring you – go for it! It is worth it.

  4. Krystyna says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20092:01 pm 

    Making the first move is how I got my last boyfriend and my current boyfriend. I agree with both of the comments above me – go for it.

  5. Wendy says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20092:40 pm 

    how do you make the first move?
    ask date?
    tell them you like them? ask them what we are now?
    (post hookup…we are now steady hookup, but i really like this boy.)
    help people?? :)

  6. Kate says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20093:22 pm 

    I’m in the same situation, except this boy lives an hour away, can you say complicated times two. I can.

    You can make the first move, with out making it seem like it. Ask him to just hang out, or go get lunch sometime. It can begin as no strings attached (or it will to him) and then maybe he’ll get the hint after you put yourself out there. And putting yourself out there always seems like a bad idea, but it really is the only way to see if feelings are mutual sometimes.

  7. Erich says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20094:56 pm 

    Are you serious… Why is this such an issue for women? I think that if you see something (someone) you like or want then you should go after it. Its just not gonna fall in your lap.

  8. E says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20096:46 pm 

    I tend to make the first move about half the time in situations like this. I find that it’s usually the same, though: if you know each other and he knows you’re into him at least a little and he hasn’t made a move, it’s because he’s not that into you. But occasionally he’s just shy. And it feels good to take the reins, why not?! The worst that can happen is awkwardness. And, let’s face it: that happens regardless.

  9. Nikki says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20098:59 pm 

    If you wanna make the first move, go ahead. I agree with everyone who says it’s better knowing than waiting.

    After all, if he likes you, he’s just gonna be thankful you made that first move. If he rejects you, that shows he can’t appreciate the forwardness of a wonderful girl like you, so ultimately, it might not work out anyway.

    How I see it, you only live once so just do it, take that chance. We all know how you feel so you’re not alone.

  10. Confused says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20099:02 pm 

    “Hes too much of a wimp to make the grand gesture.”

    I’m only a guy, but Im pretty sure making a move is the same exact thing as hitting on someone. According to this site that makes us scum and subject to ridicule, and garnering the second worst moniker in all of Brodom….”loser”.

    Gee I really wonder why this wimp hasnt antied up the sack to ask you out. Men are soooooo complicated. hahaha some people have all the nerve.

  11. Confused says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 20099:03 pm 

    “Hes too much of a wimp to make the grand gesture.”

    I’m only a guy, but Im pretty sure making a move is the same exact thing as hitting on someone. According to this site that makes us scum and subject to ridicule, and garnering the second worst moniker in all of Brodom….”loser”.

    Gee I really wonder why this wimp hasnt antied up the sack to ask the author out. OMG boyys are sooooo complicated.

  12. Tom says:
    Mon, 26th Oct 200910:57 pm 

    Fucking sack of shit. If a guy really like you he will do whatever it takes to be with you. It isn’t fucking rocket science. Guys are direct. If he isn’t with you, he doesn’t like you. Read a fucking book or something. Jesus Christ!!!!!!!!!

  13. Rachel says:
    Tue, 27th Oct 20098:08 am 

    Dear Tom. You are an idiot. Life is much more complicated than that. Why don’t YOU go read a book, and stop hanging around forums meant for girls, deluding yourself that you know everything there is to know about people you’ve never met. In conclusion, fuck off. (And no, I’m not bitter – I am actually very happy with someone who I got with after I made the first move. So don’t be discouraged girls!!!)

  14. Jenny says:
    Tue, 27th Oct 200910:33 am 

    I almost always make the first move, and it’s worked out pretty well for me in the past. :) I say go for it! What do you have to lose? If he does share your feelings, he’ll be elated that you said something. If he doesn’t, then at least you’ll know now and now weeks or months from now. Good luck!

  15. Kyle says:
    Fri, 30th Oct 200910:28 pm 

    Speaking for me personally, asking someone out is just as fraught with anxiety and self doubt as it probably is for most women. Hell, there’s a girl I’ve known forever, we’re great friends and I’d love to take it to the next level. But all the same questions the writer is having apply to me just as well.
    It’s tough out there for everyone.

  16. Kevin says:
    Thu, 5th Nov 20092:04 pm 

    I say go for it and make a move. Personally, I believe the most attractive thing about any woman is confidance and the ability to display it. That goes from walkin with posture to knowing what you want and just figuring out the way to get there. Try a change and take a step out of your comfort zone and go for it. If it works out, enjoy every last moment. But if it doesnt, dont be hard on yourself – you tried something new and learned from it. Believe it or not, some guys are shy too when it comes to a girl he likes, and you’ll never know unless you find out for urself :)

  17. the violator says:
    Fri, 6th Nov 200911:33 pm 

    yeh, the refusal/fear to make the 1st move is a prime example of why many women do not succeed as leaders or ever get into the position to lead in the real world to begin with.
    gotta have some guts ladies. more often than not when you ask the guy out, you will be pleasantly surprised.

  18. Rae says:
    Fri, 13th Nov 20092:07 am 

    Despite my equalist views (that’s the gender-equal term for “feminist” by the way), I’d never made the first move with guys before- I was always too afraid of rejection. In fact, friends of mine often had to intervene to push the guy and me together since he was usually just as shy with this sort of thing (oddly enough, most of the guys, like me, are actually outgoing in all other situations). This year though, my junior year, I finally got to a point with this one guy where I just forced myself to suck it up and flat-out ask him if he was interested. I nearly hyperventilated while waiting for a response (since I sent him a text after being too afraid to ask in person), but when I heard back from him, I was pleasantly surprised! It’s still early days, but we never would’ve even gotten to this point if I hadn’t said something- guys go through the same fear/anxiety/defense mechanism thing we go through, so SOMEONE has to be willing to try. There’s absolutely no reason it can’t be you. Go for it- either way, it’s going to let you know where you stand and put you in a better position overall.

  19. lola says:
    Sun, 6th Dec 20098:41 am 

    Make the move! I was just in the same box last night and I decided to make the move. He wasn’t interested but you know what? We only live once and I don’t feel like waiting for things to happen! Just take a deep breath. If he says no, well it hurts, I won’t lie, but at least your not wasting your time right?
    Good luck :D

  20. Victoria says:
    Sat, 2nd Jan 20109:05 pm 

    Alright… girl I am in your exact same position. There’s this guy I’ve been talking to for FOUR MONTHS (capitalized because it feels like an eternity) and nothing has happened. We talk all the time, flirt like crazy, and I’m pretty sure he likes me but he’s never said anything. Reading all these responses, I’m sort of thinking that making the first move and asking him if he’s interested is the only way anything can/will happen. If he doesn’t like me, oh well. I tried. I might lose a good friendship, but that’s life. So, take these people’s advice and go for it because nothing so terrrible can happen besides him saying no to a date or that he’s sorry but he doesn’t share your feelings. You’ll be over him in five minutes. Good luck!

Tell us what you're thinking...




COVER STORY

Your St. Patty’s Day Survival Guide Your St. Patty’s Day Survival Guide

St. Patrick’s Day is a college student’s dream come true.  Well, I... 

Discount for Being Thin? Discount for Being Thin?

We are constantly surrounded by the epic American battle to lose weight. It’s all... 

Prom: No Lesbians Allowed Prom: No Lesbians Allowed

We all remember our senior proms.  Probably the most hyped up event of our lives... 

Read More Posts From This Category

HAHA

Single. And Impatient Single. And Impatient

Call me, dammit! OK, remember that boy I was confused about earlier this year? Yeah,... 

Duke It Out: Sexting Duke It Out: Sexting

[It's pretty obvious that the average CollegeCandy reader has some very strong opinions.... 

Sexy Time: Rules of the Rebound Sexy Time: Rules of the Rebound

You think breakups are hard? Try rebound sex. That little activity is more difficult... 

Read More Posts From This Category
Overheard: What am I made o

Overheard: What am I made o

(Guy and girl in tour group, walking through campus.)
Guy: Flying’s weird. Turbulence feels like you’re … hitting a ton of small animals, or something.
Girl: Ohh-kay. Don’t know you well enough for that kind of humor yet.