Coupled. Where Are We Spending The Holidays?

Ortloff Christmas Dinner

Which family will we be dining with!?

With Halloween over and done with and Christmas decorations lining hte aisles of my local CVS, it can only mean one thing: holiday season has begun.

But along with the amazingness that is Thanksgiving and Christmas, comes with one big question:

Where the heck am I going to spend the holidays this year?!?!!

With my awesome boyfriend came an awesome family, and they’ve really welcomed me as one of their own. Fortunately, his mom made the question of “Where am I spending Thanksgiving?” easy. She got tickets for herself, her older son, Matt, and myself to go see the Dallas Cowboys game on Thanksgiving day! It’s our early Christmas present and it’s a dream come true for my boyfriend. I mean come on, he’s a guy who grew up in Texas; going to see his favorite team in the new behemoth that is Cowboy’s Stadium is the best Christmas present ever.

So now that I have one holiday checked off my list, what to do about Christmas? While it might seem like a simple answer – we’ve already done one holiday with his family, now it’s time to do one with mine – it’s actually quite tricky. With Matt’s parents divorced we have three options: spend it with my family, spend it with his dad and his family, or spend it with his mom and her family. All 3 are in different states, all three would mean missing out on others, and most would involve one of us meeting the other’s extended family.

Yikes.

So what’s a girl to do? This is all new territory for me and anyone who’s in a serious enough relationship to want to spend the holidays together and adopt one another into their families. I never thought that when I got myself a long term boyfriend I’d have to start sacrificing my holiday traditions or missing out on major family time. I love Matt and his family, but part of me wants to go back to being a kid and go home to my traditions – eating dinner with my family, opening presents with my family, actually seeing my family for the first time in months…

I know this is all just a part of growing up, but I’m really torn. I’ve never spent any major holiday away from my parents, but flying back to see them would cost the two of us almost $600! Is it worth it when we have the option of going somewhere cheaper? But then again, is it fair to keep visiting the BF’s family when mine hasn’t seen us?

Is it time that Matt and I both move past our childhood traditions and start our own?

I’m not sure what to do, but I’m going to have to figure it out fast. It’s already November and the cost of plane tickets just keeps creeping higher and higher. And the fact that Matt and I couldn’t even figure out what to do on Halloween (his friends were having a party, my friends were having a party…) isn’t leaving me much hope that we’ll come to a conclusion anytime soon.

Sigh.
Who knew holidays with a boyfriend would take so much work?!

Anybody else out there with fuzzy holiday plans?

16 Comments on "Coupled. Where Are We Spending The Holidays?"

  1. Lindsay says:
    Thu, 5th Nov 20095:04 pm 

    Go through StudentUniverse.com to get cheapy tickets, they should have something for the holidays- spring break it cost me only $345 round trip from northern vermont to miami.

  2. Casey says:
    Thu, 5th Nov 20095:25 pm 

    I feel you. My boyfriend and I are trying to decided right now too. Last year we had it at his house and invited my parents. It was the first time our parents met each other and although it wasn’t either of our traditional thanksgiving both of our families were going through stuff and this was the best option for both, not to mention it was a great opportunity for our families to meet and have dinner together.

    Since I work retail I haven’t been about to go to my traditional thanksgiving in 4 years, and it was the only time I ever saw my external family. I was looking forward to going this year and taking my boyfriend so he could get to know my family (since his entire family lives here, I already know all of them pretty well, but none of mine does and he’s only met them briefly at my sisters wedding) But then I found out my family is canceling the traditional thanksgiving this year due to my one aunt renovating her house, so another can move in with her. But we were discussing it with one of my bf’s friends the other day whose parents just got divorced, and he doesn’t know what to do either, but his cousin happens to be my bf’s bff, so we decided this is the perfect opportunity to start our own traditions, instead of deciding whose family to spend it with, we’re going to have our own and spend it with all of our friends who have also had some rough times this past year leaving their holiday plans up in the air as well.

    I think this is going to be the best Thanksgiving ever! And I get to cook everything myself, exactly how I want it.

  3. Erin says:
    Thu, 5th Nov 20096:33 pm 

    We switch off, you have to do a cycle, and because you have third party, dad, you can visit him later or even split the holiday between his parents and spend Christmas with them and New Years with him. Do it for one year. Then the next don’t go any where. Because i have the worlds shittiest job, retail, I can’t go anywhere so this year we will be spending out holiday together, lo stress no travel day together. We’ll make food and chill. It’s alot easier than trying to figure out where to spend it and have people come to your house/apartment.

  4. Laura says:
    Thu, 5th Nov 20098:46 pm 

    well, honestly, why can’t you (alone) spend it at your family? I’m sure your family misses you very much, and want nothing more than to spend a couple days with you. I’m also sure your boyfriend is a really great guy and all, but wouldn’t your parent rather catch up with you, instead of you and matt? committed relationships are tricky in college, trust me, I’m in one! But me and my boyfriend have always gone our separate way for Christmas. Not for all holidays, but for holidays that are special to us and our family, ie Christmas. i believe that it’s too early to be spending all the holidays together all the time! you’re in college! you’re not married! You will have all the time in the world to divide up holidays when you guys get older, why are you trying to do it now?

  5. Emily says:
    Thu, 5th Nov 20099:00 pm 

    My boyfriend and I are splitting up for Thanksgiving, but he is joining my family Thanksgiving night for our traditional hockey game. For Christmas, I am spending Christmas Day at his mom’s place with his family because he is going on vacation with my entire family and we leave the next day. It’s hard to decide and my mom keeps telling me I can spend Thanksgiving with him if I want, but I kind of want one more familiar holiday because the holidays last year were kind of weird for us in terms of who’s family to spend them with.

    My advice is just to go with your gut. Sometimes that one holiday how you had it as a kid is an amazing thing, especially as a de-stresser from the last semester. Good luck with deciding!

  6. Dannia says:
    Fri, 6th Nov 20094:00 am 

    I’m with Laura on this one… I think you should both probably spend it with your families! I know you want to share so many milestones together but if you believe that he’s the one and you’re going to get married one day, then there’s no need to rush the whole holiday thing… you aren’t married yet, so his family are technically not your in-laws (though you may feel that close). You will hopefully have many, many years to create your own family and traditions and until you do… I think spending the holidays with your own parents is the best way to go.

  7. mary says:
    Fri, 6th Nov 20093:35 pm 

    me and my boyfriend split up for thanksgiving, and then all of our friends meet up later that night – we live pretty close to each other – same county. and then on the 24th, we hang out w/ each of our families during the day. my mom’s bday is the 24th also so that adds to it, he comes over later that night and spends it with us. my family opens presents then, and then i spend christmas at his house. on new year’s we hang out with our friends. this is going to be the 3rd year we’ve done it.

    i recommend going home for christmas by yourself.

  8. Kaila says:
    Fri, 6th Nov 200910:06 pm 

    I’ve got it nice and easy, since holidays aren’t that big of a deal with my fam, I go to my bfs house for thanksgiving then we spend christmas with our own seperate families. I don’t really mind spending christmas apart.

  9. R says:
    Sat, 7th Nov 20099:55 am 

    I don’t know if you celebrate X-mas eve but my family spends x-mas eve night with my dads side and then x-mas day with my moms side. Maybe you could spend one day with our bf’s dad and the other with your own family. It would be a ton of traveling though. But I also agree with Laura, you guys are not even married yet so maybe spending the holidays apart would be better and cheaper.

  10. Danielle says:
    Sun, 8th Nov 20097:04 pm 

    See I went to university in my hometown, so I figured I’d spend half of my winter break with my boyfriend who is in the Air Force this year. Yea I’ll miss Christmas with my parents but as much as I love them every year there is always a family argument and I kinda end up feeling alone so I figured why not? As for you I say go home if you haven’t been back in a while, your boyfriend can decide to come with or go visit his. *Note there is always the option of getting that tree, decorating it, and celebrating your (first?) Christmas together that way no one feels like you choose another family.

  11. Kate says:
    Mon, 9th Nov 20093:08 pm 

    Honestly… you’re spending one of the major holidays with his family (Thanksgiving)- I think he should be open to spending Christmas with your family. That’s balanced. Otherwise I would say spend it with just your own families- I know you always must want to be with him, but if you guys get married one day you’re not going to get to see you’re own family so much… as a previous poster said, if you guys are really serious and might get married one day, why not just spend at least one of the holidays with your own family- you’ll be living with him for the rest of your life if you guys get married (And that’s a lot of Thanksgivings and Christmases to spend with him and his family:) ).

  12. Tara says:
    Wed, 11th Nov 200911:36 am 

    Um… I think we are life-twins. I also have a boyfriend named Matt, who I have been together with for a while. (Not 8 years, wow, congrats girl.) His parents are ALSO divorced, while mine are not. So I totally feel for you about having to add not just one, but TWO more christmas traditions to schedule. Also similar to you, (but opposite) Matt is spending Thanksgiving with my family this year. Which SHOULD mean I head over to one of his family’s celebrations for Christmas… right? But I am also feeling the tug of my childhood pulling me toward everything I know and love about the holidays in my family. Both of our families are pretty close to us, so traveling is not a factor for us fortunately. But Matt and I are deciding to spend Christmas Eve with our own families and then get together on Christmas Day. May I suggest finding a Christmas Day flight? After all, we are still pretty young. Let’s enjoy it while we can. If you truly believe you will have many more christmases with your Matt (and it sounds like you are well on your way) I say just enjoy being young and look forward to your future Christmases as a couple. You’ve got time. Good luck.

    P.S. One last weird similarity… My Matt’s dad always gives us his season tickets to the MN Gopher games. Our boys sure to love football. Weird…

  13. Maria says:
    Wed, 11th Nov 20094:04 pm 

    I don’t think you should spend holidays awa from your family until you get married or living as such! you will at some point regret missing out your family…and if it ends up not working out you will be even more sorry! Plenty of years ahead to make compromises!

  14. Angela says:
    Thu, 19th Nov 20094:11 am 

    I think your best choice is to start having vacations on your own, even if it costs you more. If you are worried about the budget then search through Elysian Holidays for your accommodation and you will get a reasonable price for a fully equipped holiday vacation villa.

  15. Sara says:
    Mon, 23rd Nov 20098:56 pm 

    We’ve been together for (on and off) 8 years now (4 1/2 years straight). My mom passed 5 years ago, my grandpa passed 3 years ago, and my dad almost passed 3 years ago. Lately my dad hasn’t been too confident about hanging around in this world. Since my mom passed, my bf and I have shared holidays with both families. This year would be my turn to spend with his but I’m concerned about not having another year with my dad or Grandma. My family is getting smaller sooner rather than later, while his keeps growing. I hate feeling selfish about this, but it’s not like he’s in any hurry to make US a family therefore I feel somewhat justified. I feel if we WERE married, our family would come first and we would be forced to choose how to split up the holidays – I told him how I felt and he’s just hurt to not spend them with me. Our families are 2 hours apart, therefore the Thanksgiving 2 meal day isn’t really an option. I hate not having moved to the next step, and at this point, I’d rather be there for my dad. Any words of encouragement?

Tell us what you're thinking...




COVER STORY

21 Things I Learned in My 21st Year 21 Things I Learned in My 21st Year

#9: Reading for pleasure is magical. Make time for it! Just last February, I was... 

Take Action to End Violence Against Women Take Action to End Violence Against Women

One of the most important issues we are facing today is violence against women. Based... 

The Sober One The Sober One

It took until the middle of my junior year of college, but I finally went to my first... 

Read More Posts From This Category

HAHA

Show Yourself Some Love This Valentine’s Day Show Yourself Some Love This Valentine’s Day

For us single girls, Valentine’s Day can seriously suck. Even if you love... 

Single. On Valentine’s Day Single. On Valentine’s Day

So I don’t know if you’ve heard, but Valentine’s Day is coming up. Yes, as... 

The CC Weekly Weigh In: Significant Jerks The CC Weekly Weigh In: Significant Jerks

I'd rather spend my V-day crying into a bowl of noodles than have to hang out... 

Read More Posts From This Category
From Popeater: Will Ellen Boost Idol’s Ratings?

From Popeater: Will Ellen Boost Idol’s Ratings?

After months of speculation, Ellen DeGeneres will finally have the chance to prove herself worthy of the seat between ‘American Idol’ judges Kara, Randy and Simon. Tuesday night marks her much anticipated ‘Idol’ debut, replacing former judge Paula Abdul.