sarah says:
Thu, 9th Jun 20115:24 pm 

Ridiculously hot.

Audrina says:
Thu, 9th Jun 20115:33 pm 

Hot! She's 18, turning 19 this year. thats not too young to do sexy!

Cara says:
Thu, 9th Jun 20116:06 pm 

HOT if she was 16 i would say too young…but 18 way hot!

Lily says:
Thu, 9th Jun 20116:38 pm 

As a 21-year-old who still looks like she’s a high school sophomore, I totally think that it’s hard for girls like us to be “sexy”. I think Selena should be able to wear a sexy dress, despite her baby face. She, like Miley Cyrus( huge tramp), is legal but at least she’s not shoving it in people’s faces like Cyrus does. I think Selena’s dress was the right mix of sexy yet classy. She is an 18 year old girl, not a 15 year old. Age appropriate my bum, like you said, when you were 18 you wore sluttier clothing.

Ally says:
Thu, 9th Jun 20117:16 pm 

I'm the same age as Selena and look quite young (most people think I'm 16 or 17). I go with the sexy look when I go out…if I go with something a little more "bright and fun", I end up looking even younger! 19 is definitely not too young to do sexy, even if you don't look your age.

Theresa says:
Thu, 9th Jun 20118:16 pm 

If she is a baby then so are you…there is only a 2 1/2 year age difference. You speak as if she is old enough to be one of your children. I think she looks fabulous but really even if she looks a mess she bought it so who cares!

Amy says:
Thu, 9th Jun 201110:17 pm 

Selena looks absolutely stunning! The only problem I have is that she is still a Disney channel star. I know that she is of age, but we have to remember that young children (not only girls) look up to her. She has a responsibility to hold a positive image to these children, and that does not include the insinuation that only sexy = desirable. I'm not saying that she is pushing the bar here, I'm just hoping that she keeps it at this level or lower clothing or action wise, and remember she chose to be a role model to kids.

Michele says:
Thu, 9th Jun 201110:23 pm 

Half of the CC writers have mixed opinions on the "slut-shaming" issue. Remember that article about trying not to be "whorey"? Even though it's not right to slut-shame, girls will never stop being catty towards one another.
On the other hand, I agree with Lily that Miley goes over-the-top with her sexuality. Sure, Miley's 18 or whatever but that doesn't mean she should be full-on-porn-star, especially with the fan base she had. As a teen celebrity, she should have known that she would be in so much scrutiny for making life choices (like smoking saliva) and that she is a role model to young girls, whether she likes it or not. Selena seems to be more conscientious about this and I think that she is doing a good job transitioning from a young teenager into a classy and respectable adult without shaking up so much controversy.
All in all, Miley isn't exactly a classy person and therefore she is more prone to getting less than classy comments from others.

sarah says:
Fri, 10th Jun 20112:43 am 

I agree with you that Miley sometimes takes it over the top – but I don't think anyone should judge her based on what she wears. And she never looks like a full-on-porn-star, I don't even know where you got that from. Anyway, I agree that she should be respectful of her fan-base and should be a good role-model, but that still doesn't mean we can blame other girls' behaviour on one person. And, of course she is prone to getting less than classy comments from others, and she should expect that, but those kind of names are completely inappropriate. And lastly – it's salvia*

Luanne Dulay says:
Fri, 10th Jun 20114:55 am 

Or maybe because you grew up watching her in Barney! We also can't get used to the fact that she's all grown up now and dating JB! She's still a baby…=)

My daughter with Autism just loves her in Barney. We watch her everyday.

yasmine says:
Fri, 10th Jun 20117:22 am 

i totally see where youre coming from Charlotte- i'm surprised to see this many people approve of her wearing a dress that was definitely not designed with an 18 yr old in mind.

Sarah T says:
Fri, 10th Jun 20118:20 am 

She looks gorgeous! There are plenty of things worse for someone her age to wear than a classy black dress. I don't think it's ever a problem for young people to look "too sophisticated" – what a welcome change from some of the sloppy/trashy outfits young girls can often be seen in!

Jessica - Hofstra says:
Fri, 10th Jun 201110:07 am 

The dress is a little bit too old for her, but she still looks amazing. She can totally pull it off! She looks fab.

mave says:
Fri, 10th Jun 201112:09 pm 

luvly outfit. selena luks stunning in black. who cares abt age here. u go girl!!!!

Joyce says:
Fri, 10th Jun 20116:50 pm 

To the author: you sound quite jealous of Selena.

Toni says:
Mon, 13th Jun 20116:00 pm 

I don't think it's too old at all. I remember Miley's red oscar gown looking too old on her, but this dress seems young and fresh. I think if someone like Blake Lively with a lot of clevage wore it, it could maybe come off as too revealing, but not with Selena's shape. I think she finally looks like a woman. And I love how her hair is styled. Makes it less harsh.

izle says:
Mon, 13th Jun 201110:01 pm 

It is a gorgeous dress but it definitely does not go with her. She does not have the face, body or attitude for it. She looks and acts like an annoying 8 year old.

Courtney says:
Thu, 16th Jun 20111:14 am 

Have you seen the outfits she wears on stage? She looks like shes ready to give it up to anyone who's taking. I dont have a problem with her wanting to dress or act like a slut but shes a role model for kids. (And fyi this isnt me slut-shaming, being slutty isnt a bad thing as long as you arent doing it infront of kids.)

Ashleigh says:
Sun, 19th Jun 20116:59 pm 

I think she looks absolutely stunning. Yes, she's showing skin but not in a vulgar way or even overly sexy. She is making a sophisticated transition from child star to adult