Should I Dump My High School Boyfriend?

August 22, 2011 2:00 pm     Posted in Advice, Back to School, College, Featured Right, Relationships  The Dude g+ page

High school, that little local bubble of a world (unless you’re in an out of state school for one reason or another). A lot of couples are practically tied to the hip when graduation comes and then there’s the decision that has to be made: “Do I take the relationship to college with me?”

The answer to this question is no…I think? Usually? It depends, right? I mean if you’re…but on the hand if you’re…Damn you, game of life! How dare you be so on the fence?

There are some key questions to confront (separately and together) when deciding whether to “take a break” from each other to explore the college frontier. For instance, is he going to the same college as you? If the answer is yes, then, well, that makes things…yeah. On the other hand, if you’re going to be on different continents and there’s no possibility of seeing each other for months on end then, well, yeah! You see? Circumstances!

There are a million and a half variables to consider. How long have you been together? Have you dropped the L bomb yet? How far apart will you be? Are you only together because the dating pool at your high school was less ripe than after each year at Sunnydale High (you know, cause all the monsters and vampires would kill off so many students that there must have only been a few options…yeah…GILES!).

Plenty of couples decide to give it the ol’ college try. I can’t think of one that worked out. But that’s just me. I’m sure it must have for someone. However, all my experiences and observations seem to indicate that the high school sweethearts who make it all the way to the college graduation stage-without having broken up at some point-is the BIG exception, not the rule.

I’ve known people who got engaged to keep the relationship together. By junior year, the wedding was off. On the other hand, I’ve known couples who’ve given each other space with the full intent of seeing where things stood a year later. When the time came to reconnect they were both standing on different ground.

College is a time for self-discovery. You try new things, meet a lot of new people, and need to be emotionally open to help develop into the next phase of your life.  You really don’t know what’s going to happen. A lifetime of experiences is going to engulf you every, single, year. It’s tough to imagine that’s true but stretch your creative faculties. And still, you don’t know what you’re in for or how much college will affect you.

Being committed when you arrive can be a great source of self-protection and comfort for the adjustment period. But to make the relationship last will take A LOT of work. And I mean WORK! You can’t just go over to each other’s house after school or know you’ll see each other every day in/between/after classes. Are you ready to give your commitment that kind of commitment? It’ll mean sacrificing some of the college experience. Although, one could argue a valid college experience is trying to hold onto a high school relationship…stupid, twisty-turny, timey-wimey life *kicks can down the street*

The best you can do is weigh the pros with the cons. What will the relationship give you and what will it take away from the next step? There’s no question that your high school boyfriend can be a major drain on your college social life. And believe me, developing a college social life is a major part of the experience and contributes to your evolution into adulthood. And the lack thereof will too.

If all’s well and you both want to give it a go, then, hey, why not? You’ll find out soon enough if it won’t hold up. Just beware: the break up will be messier.

On the other hand, if you’re just having a good time right now then a clean break before you start earning credits might be the best possible thing for both of you. Sure, it’ll hurt, but it’ll hurt worse later.

Who knows though, maybe, just maybe, you and your beau could be the one in a million that lasts.

The choice is yours and it’s circumstantial. Take a look around and see where you both are and how deep you’re in.

I’ve given you all the warnings from every perspective I could while not closing the door on any of the possible choices one can make. Now comes my opinion: Take a break. Doesn’t have to be permanent, but you’ll be surprised to find that it might be necessary…

Your orientation leader,

The Dude

13 Comments on "Should I Dump My High School Boyfriend?"
  1. therelationshipflunkie says:
    Mon, 22nd Aug 20113:30 pm 

    Really – I just want to 'Like' this and not post a comment. . .

  2. Rebecca says:
    Mon, 22nd Aug 20114:01 pm 

    I've just graduated . I know three HS couples that stayed together through college and many many more that didn't. I stayed with my HS boyfriend although we eventually broke up halfway through freshman year.

    I definitely don't regret the decision to stay with him as I went to college. I didn't sacrifice my college social or academic life for him or use the relationship as a crutch. In the end the relationship died a natural death and three years later we're both happy in other relationships. I actually found it easier breaking up knowing we tried but the relationship wasn't right. If we'd split up when I first went to college and was still head over heals in love with him, I would have been distracted, miserable and constantly second guessing the decision.

  3. Ali says:
    Mon, 22nd Aug 20115:16 pm 

    There are a lot of articles on this site about staying or not staying with your high school boyfriend, but I also think it'd be useful to see an article about staying with your college boyfriend once you enter the real world. Graduating college with a boyfriend seems almost harder than the decision to bring a boyfriend into college, because the relationships are typically more serious but due to grad schools and jobs you may have no other option than to end up in completely different cities, whereas with a high school boyfriend you usually at least have your hometown in common. And selfishly, I've been looking for advice because I'll have to deal with this in less than a year :)

  4. Victoria says:
    Mon, 22nd Aug 20119:15 pm 

    In the spring of this year, I started dating a guy two years younger than me. When I first found out that he was interested in me, I was very hesitant to start a relationship with him, because I would be moving to college almost a thousand miles away in only a few months. We dated anyways, and had a wonderful three month relationship, even though we knew it had to end at some definite point. And then we broke up the day before I left.

    I've been single for less than two weeks. Do I still love him and miss him? Absolutely. Do I regret our decision to break up? Of course not. In fact, I'm happy that the relationship ended because of college, and not because of cheating or fighting. We still talk and text, but we've realized that we are at different stages in our lives, and should see other people. Who knows? If it's meant to be, then we'll get back together someday. But in the meantime, I haven't really lost a boyfriend so much as gained a close friend.

  5. Ariana says:
    Mon, 22nd Aug 20119:25 pm 

    I have a really different situation… My senior year I started dating a man 4 years older in his first year of his masters program… He lives an hour from my hometown and 20 minutes from my dorm. Going to college I’m closer to him and I can say I really do love him! Going to college and staying with him was a no brainer because I see myself with no one else ,but him for the rest of my life :)

  6. Ariana says:
    Mon, 22nd Aug 20119:26 pm 

    *senior in highschool — oops

  7. Anna says:
    Sun, 28th Aug 20118:24 pm 

    thanks for such a thoughtful article on the subject…and props for Buffy and Doctor Who references, too. ;)

  8. @LiaSteinb says:
    Wed, 31st Aug 20111:41 am 

    I met my boyfriend during our sophomore year of high school and we are graduating college this fall. We haven't broken up once during our relationship and we're perfectly happy. Just giving an example of a relationship that does work. It's definitely hard work, but it's not impossible.

  9. marie says:
    Wed, 7th Sep 20111:11 pm 

    or you could just say that most relationships you enter when you are 16-18 won`t last that long. college, university, same town, different town or not. school, while with it`s complications isn`t the only thing that causes breakups. it`s the growing up, developing as people, changing and realising the people you have become don`t fit so well anymore. school maybe just highlights it a bit faster

  10. samuel christian says:
    Tue, 24th Jan 20124:20 am 

    What an interesting post to read, thanks for bringing it up.

Tell us what you're thinking...