In Our Makeup Bag: Mary Kay Cream Eye Color

January 31, 2012 1:00 pm     Posted in Reality  Alex K. g+ page


By Alex K.

What It Is:

Mary Kay Cream Eye Color in Pale Blush, Beach Blonde and Apricot Twist

Why This Should Be in Your Bag:

Cream eyeshadows are a great and versatile tool to have in your makeup bag. They can be used on their own, to give a shiny wash of color, or as a base to give longevity to your powder shadows or amp up their pigmentation. I love using cream shadows when I don’t have much time to do my makeup; they help me to look polished and are so quick!

Mary Kay is a brand you don’t see much of on beauty blogs. It’s sold through consultants, as opposed to the internet or giant beauty chains, and is often overlooked. However, I think this brand has a few gems to offer and I can’t wait to share them with you!

How To Use It:

Just like most cream eyeshadows, the Mary Kay Cream Eye Color come in small, round pots with twist-off lids. I prefer to apply them with my finger, but any stiff, flat brush will do. The initial swipe of color is slightly sheer, but fear not, you can build these babies up to your liking.

Like I alluded to earlier, you can also use these as a primer or base to intensify your shadows and make your look long-wearing. Check out the swatches below to see how the shades compare.

(L-R: Apricot Twist, Pale Blush, Beach Blonde)

CC Rating: A+

I have to admit, I was totally hesitant about the Mary Kay Cream Eye Colors. MAC Paint Pots, which are pretty much the holy-grail of cream eyeshadows, don’t really work on me and end up creasing or melting away. However, I was pleasantly surprised! Beach Blonde lasted ALL DAY on me, with no creasing for at least 6-7 hours.

Application was also a dream. I find Benefit’s Creaseless Creams to be a bit too slippery, but Mary Kay Cream Eye Color was thicker and made it easy to apply a proper layer. They reminded me of Maybelline Color Tattoos, but didn’t dry down the second they were applied; I was still able to work with it a bit. My favorite thing has to be that they are so pigmented – sheer cream eyeshadows drive me insane!

And the prices is also a winner for me. At only $13.50, these are cheaper than all of the alternatives I’ve mentioned (except the new Maybelline Color Tattoos). If you’re a cream eyeshadow lover or looking for a new base, you need to check out Mary Kay Cream Eye Color!

[Need some new makeup but not sure what to buy? Check out Alex's other beauty reviews here.]

40 Comments on "In Our Makeup Bag: Mary Kay Cream Eye Color"

  1. Randi says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:08 pm 

    Fabulous comments – THANK YOU!
    I'm an Independent Beauty Consultant for Mary Kay and love to hear you make such positive remarks in comparison to other brands. I will say, however, the cream shadows are actually only $13 so even a bit more savings than what you mentioned.

  2. Celeste says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:11 pm 

    MaryKay.com/CelesteBall -Free shipping!!

  3. Jodi says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:22 pm 

    I am also an Independent Beauty Consultant and another awesome benefit of Mary Kay is that you get to try products BEFORE you buy! Head to http://www.marykay.com to find a consultant near you

  4. Nancy Cirje says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:23 pm 

    Great review! If you live in Chicago and need a MK consultant check out and "like' "Shop Mary Kay with Fancy Nancy" & let me help you get beautiful!! xo!

  5. Martha Matheson says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:24 pm 

    Fabulous! I LOVE to hear people who discover Mary Kay as well. It is truly the best known little secret that I love to spread… thanks for passing this along

  6. Nancy Cirje says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:26 pm 

    http://www.marykay.com/nancirje5
    Facebook blog – Shop Mary Kay with Fancy Nancy

  7. Hilary says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:30 pm 

    Fabulous (and true!) review, Alex. :) And the Cream Eye Colors are actually only $13! If anyone reading this is a "Mary Kay orphan" and isn't currently being serviced by a professional beauty consultant, please feel free to contact me! I welcome all questions, with no obligation to purchase…but keep a full inventory in stock if you do find something you fall in love with. Shipping in the continental U.S. is FREE with me. Give the new Mary Kay a try — especially if it's been a few years since your last facial. Skype appointments available, too!

  8. Alicia Hugee says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:47 pm 

    Thanks Alex! I am also an Independent Beauty Consultant. Thanks for the great review of our awesome product. I am also hear to meet all beauty needs… Shop online with me 24/7 @ http://www.marykay.com/ahugee. No lines and no waiting…

  9. Adriana says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20124:54 pm 

    Hillary,
    Go to www. Marykay.com/aprince24
    You will no longer be an orphan!!!!

  10. sass butler says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20125:18 pm 

    One of my favorite MK things!! I love love love mine!!

  11. Sherri says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20125:34 pm 

    Love that our products are getting great reviews, Mary Kay has been around for decades but is fresh new and updated for customers in every age group and demographic!

    I too am a consultant and can help anyone any time. Shipping is always free and there is a 100% money back gurantee on all products.
    http://www.marykay.com/sherrimoeller

  12. Sarah says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20125:47 pm 

    LOVE!!! I wear these alone for a quick "dash out the door" look, or I wear it as a primer/base color when I do the full glam look. One word of warning – I maaaay have been doing my makeup in the car (while stopped of course) and dropped the cap of my fav pale blush under the seat. I was in a hurry and figured I'd find it later. Within 24 hours it was dried up and ruined :/ SO, keep the caps on this product so you can enjoy every last bit of it!

  13. MARY MCCRAINE says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20125:58 pm 

    I AM A MARY KAY CONSULTANT. MY FAVORITE THING IS THE SATIN HANDS..34 DLRS PLUS TAX. THERE IS A SOFTNER A SCRUB/ AND A CREAM. IT KEEPS THE HANDS SOFT FOR 24 HRS. I LOVE IT.

  14. anne olah says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20126:25 pm 

    Love the positive feedback! I'm a MK consultant in PA… .www.marykay.com/aolahj

  15. Theresa Johnson says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20126:49 pm 

    Fantastic! Thank you Alex for your rave review. As you can see Mary Kay has a loyal following. We Independent Beauty Consultants are always willing to help anyone with their skin care and color cosmetic needs. For anyone that does not presently have a personal consultant; I would be honored to help you. Visit my website and check out our #1 Product lines.
    http://www.marykay.com/theresajohnson

  16. kathy says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20126:55 pm 

    I love these. They are my best sellers. Sooooo easy to put on with your fingers or a brush! Order yours at http://www.marykay.com/klammersmaas when you spend $40 ou receive our new lip gloss set free.

  17. Lola says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20127:01 pm 

    Love the colors! They stary on forever!

  18. Karen Everson says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20127:03 pm 

    Thank you for the great review. Mary Kay products are the best. As a Independent Beauty Consultant I love to help woman with all thier skin care and cosmetic needs. I am located in south eastern Minnesota. http://www.marykay.com/kareneverson. Thank you once again!

  19. Bobbie Sue Jalufka says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20128:05 pm 

    This is amazing!!! I am in South Texas and I love my hostess, if you book a class with me, let me come do glamour and skin care, then as a hostess you can shop for a great price!!!! I love my life and I love making women feel amazing :) ))) http://www.marykay.com/bobbiesuejalufka

  20. Donna Fearnow says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20128:40 pm 

    I'm a Mary Kay consultant in Mechanicsville, Va. I love the cream eyeshadows, too. They are so easy to use and the colors are great! Call me to try these and Mary Kay's other great products! http://www.marykay.com/dfearnow

  21. Patricia says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 20129:58 pm 

    Alex, great review! I too am a Mary Kay Consultant in the Atlanta area. If anyone wants to try the cream shadows for themselves, just contact me. I offer free shipping, and personalized service, so if there is anything you want to try, please contact me. Pat

  22. Linda Hannemann says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 201210:31 pm 

    Thank you for your article. I love, love, love these cream eye colors, and the fact that they don't migrate to the creases is awesome. I am a Mary Kay Independent beauty consultant and my favorite part of my job is showing others these great products. You can contact me and try these before you buy them. http://www.marykay.com/lhannemann1

  23. Christy says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 201210:59 pm 

    I <3 the MK cream eye shadows!

  24. Marilyn says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 201211:00 pm 

    Order yours at http://www.marykay.com/mglowa with free shipping and get our free gift with a $40 order; they are pretty and long lasting shadows.

  25. Mary Williams says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 201211:21 pm 

    I am a Mary Kay consultant in San Antonio, TX. The cream eyeshadows are great. They can help your special look last twice as long. Contact me if you would like to try these or other Mary Kay products. You will be glad you did. http://www.marykay.com/mhwilliams

  26. Noellemq says:
    Mon, 6th Feb 201211:35 pm 

    Thanks so much for your great review! I am a Mary Kay Consultant in the San Francisco Bay Area and love, love, love the cream eye shadows. Like you said, they are "buildable" colors and stand so well on their own or you can use as a primer for your powder shadows. The color possibilities are endless! http://www.marykay.com/nmarroquin

  27. Shannon Long says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 201212:03 am 

    I am an Independent Beauty Consultant with Mary Kay. Love this article!! Mary Kay cosmetics and skincare is unbelievable and 100% satisfaction guaranteed so you never have to worry about what you purchase!! I’m in the Cartersville, Georgia area so if your needing a consultant contact me and you can shop online with me 24/7 free shipping and free gift with purchase over $40!! http://www.marykay.com/shannonlong

  28. Sherry says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 20122:55 am 

    Thank you for your review of Mary Kay’s creme eye-shadow! You are right, MK has so much to offer in the way of superior cosmetics and skin care for all ages! I’m always looking for sharp young women to join my fantastic team of consultants in Seattle, WA and get all of their products for 50% off! email me if you’re looking for cosmetics or if you’d like to know more about the Mary Kay business! Sherry @ grimace36@yahoo.com

  29. Sharon Rae Cieslik says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 20127:14 am 

    Love my Mary Kay Creme Eyeshadows! Great dash out
    the door look. Want some? shop 24/7 at http://www.marykay.com/sharonrae

  30. Gina says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 20128:33 am 

    Absolutely my favorite Mary Kay product. I've been a Mary Kay consultant for 19 years in the Farmington, MN and Twin Cities area. I sell lots of the $13 Cream Eye Shadow Pots as well as the Flat, Stiff Brush to go with them ($10) …for expert application. Check it all out at MaryKay.com and email me to order: thorseufer@hotmail.com I always ship Free of Charge!!

  31. Terry says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 20128:45 am 

    Thanks for the great review. I love the cream eye shadows as both a base and quick look! Check out the great makeover ideas at my website http://www.marykay.com/tmcdermid in the Virtual Makeover. Need a consultant? I’m in SW Missouri.

  32. Kevin Garcia says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 20129:22 am 

    Great colors, Awsome products Mary Kay is the way!!!!

    Male consultant in the area of Miami!!!
    http://www.marykay.com/keving087

  33. Connie says:
    Tue, 7th Feb 20121:19 pm 

    Yep, I'm a Mary Kay consultant in Florida and I just love those cream eye colors. I have sold a lot of it and my customers love them too. Makes your eyes look polished and you can wear them alone all over your eyelid and put an eyeliner and you can go. Or you can use it as a base for your eyeshadows – versatile!

  34. Valencia says:
    Wed, 8th Feb 201212:43 am 

    I am a Mary Kay consultant in Connecticut (Fairfield county area) and minutes away from the New York. I'm always looking for sharp young women to join my fantastic team of consultants in Connecticut/New York area and take advantage of all of the benefits of the business. Email me if you're looking for cosmetics or if you'd like to know more about the Mary Kay business! http://www.marykay.com/vemile

  35. Barbara Ortiz says:
    Sun, 12th Feb 20129:53 pm 

    I am a Mary Kay consultant in Fayette County West Virginia and I'm always looking for sharp young women to join my fantastic team of consultants in West Virginia and take advantage of all of the benefits of the business. Email me if you're looking for cosmetics or if you'd like to know more about the Mary Kay business! http://www.marykay.com/bortiz6975.

  36. Kate says:
    Wed, 23rd May 201211:44 am 

    These cream eye shadows are fantastic! They are crease-resistant and act as a primer!! I use the Beach Blonde or Apricot Twist daily as a base for my mineral eye colors. For $13, you can't beat this!! I'm also a consultant..surprise, surprise. haha ;) I'm having a sale on all Mary Kay products this week: $10 off every $50 purchase plus Free Shipping and Free Samples with your order. Promo code is 10OFF and please note that the discount will be applied once the order is placed. Feel Free to share the love and tell your friends! Happy Shopping!!
    Some other recommendations: the Ultimate Mascara, Microdermabrasion Set, TimeWise Foundation & Primer, Miracle Set and Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover.

  37. Jessica Smith Wallace says:
    Mon, 18th Jun 20121:53 pm 

    I am new to selling mary kay but this is a def. necessity in my purse! I love these eyeshadows. if you need product email me at r.j.masquerade@gmail.com ! would be so glad to take your order and send you your products as soon as they arrive!!! Try using beach blonde as a base under bright mineral shadows to revive energy in bright colors and make them beautiful!!!!!

  38. Alice "Liz" Crowe says:
    Sun, 20th Jan 20135:03 pm 

    Mid winter balls are coming up. Fun is just on the horizon! Stock up with our Botantical collection are try out one of our new lip glosses! Visit my website to slect your favorites and then email me with your order or even quicker order online with your credit card!

  39. shane says:
    Fri, 25th Jan 201311:21 am 

    I like the Too Faced Shadow Insurance, too! The tube lasts me about 2 years! I tend to agree with you; I really wish they were more accessible for online shopping.

    Best Eye Cream for Dark Circles

Tell us what you're thinking...