Madonna’s Super Bowl half time performance received split reactions from viewers, and the CollegeCandy office was divided down the middle with lovers and haters. The result? We let one of editors and one of our writers go head to head for an all out battle on the matter.

Jenny, CollegeCandy’s Editor-In-Chief thought Madge’s performance was one of the greatest things she’s ever seen! (Okay, that might be taking it a little far…but it was better than the Black Eyed Peas fiasco of 2011.) Garnet, CC’s lovely and talented intern, happened to think otherwise. Was Madonna’s performance hot or not? Read what our girls had to say, then leave your own comments below!

JENNY: Madonna is 53 and STILL dances like Beyonce!
GARNET: Madonna is 53 and should know better than to wear weird pointy gold headpieces

JENNY: The whole performance was over the top and fantastical- exactly what we would expect from Madonna and definitely super bowl worthy. There can be no doubt in anyone’s mind–she’s still got it.
GARNET: Madge is desperate – she’s worried no one will buy her new album, so she did the halftime show for free and went overboard trying to make it cool.

JENNY: She even ‘slips’ to the beat. I’ve never seen a better recovery to an almost accident. Give the girl some credit, she was dancing on bleachers in three inch heels!
GARNET: She was dancing, and she even sounded like she was actually singing, but the way she said “I’m sexy and I know it” like somebody’s mom ruined the whole thing.

JENNY: Quite possibly the coolest stage/lighting effects of all time. Anyone on MDMA, I mean, listening to MDNA would say it was a perfect representation of the new album.
GARNET: The lights were awesome, I’ll give you that. But there were only a few good shots of the stage from far away where we could really see what was happening. Most of the time, we were just seeing awkward close ups of Madonna shaking her nonexistent booty. The woman is like one giant muscle.

JENNY: Hey, there was no wardrobe malfunction, and she blew the Black Eyed Peas out of the water.
GARNET: Madonna’s entire outfit was a wardrobe malfunction. What was that on her head? And she looked like she was going to break her back dancing in those heels.

GARNET: Gladiators, really? What a bizarre theme, especially when Madonna started by singing “Vogue.” I loved seeing Madge sing some of her older songs, but I think “Vogue” would have been better if she had actually been voguing. I mean, come on.
JENNY: The last song on her new album is “Beautiful Killer” and no one makes a hotter gladiator than Madonna.

GARNET: Lady… Madonna? Lady Gaga rightfully gets lots of flack for imitating Madonna – almost everything she does, Madonna did first. But those gladiator boys look an awful lot like the dancers in “Alejandro.” Come on Madonna, you’re the queen. Don’t copy Lady Gaga.
JENNY: Did “Alejandro” have slackline acrobats? Back flips on a bouncing tight rope tops all dry humping in Gaga’s video. Where Gaga did trashy, Madonna goes classy.

GARNET: LMFAO makes everything bad. The show died the minute they came on stage. I didn’t think “Party Rock Anthem” could get any worse, until Madonna straddled one of the guys from LMFAO and things got ugly. I think I died a little inside when Madonna joined in for the “everyday I’m shufflin” dance.
JENNY: BUT Cee Lo Green makes everything better. I won’t argue that LMFAO lessened the performance quality (I mean, really, WTF were they wearing?), but Cee Lo and the marching band more than compensated.

GARNET: M.I.A. looked like she was going to die of boredom. And you know it was a boring show when the one part everyone remembers was M.I.A. giving the camera the finger.
JENNY: M.I.A. would use any opportunity to make a statement. It was the only way she could compete with Madonna’s spotlight.

GARNET: World peace, really? Sure, Madge, I’m all for world peace. But you thought it would be a good idea to add that right after “Like A Prayer,” the song about blowjobs? I guess that’s one way to go about it.
JENNY: True or false: The world would be a more peaceful place if more people had orgasms…

What do your favorite TV stars watch?

Are celebs more screwed up than us?

Stealing the style of the ladies of ‘Bachelorette’

Give Madonna all your luvin’

The best ‘Twilight’ vs. ‘Hunger Games’ battle

Introducing your man to toys

Can you really be friends with an ex?

Who isn’t in love with Tinker Bell inspired makeup?

Learning from sad celebrity breakups

5 ways to pretend it’s summertime.

Anne Hathaway and Kelly Osbourne get dressed up.

The most obvious Oscar snubs.

Madonna makes a poor fashion choice.

Jimmy Fallon sued for hiring … a woman?

Must see fashion documentaries.

How to have healthy relationships.

Do you remember 2gether!?

It’s ok to fight the jiggle.

Surprise, Taylor Swift writes songs about love and heartbreak.

Beyonce got a gold-butted fly named after her.

“Bridesmaids” has an element of truth to it.

Katy Perry has dyed her hair blue. It is the color of sadness…?

Heather Locklear hospitalized after combining pills and booze.

Would you wear a collarless coat?

Betty White’s funniest, and sexiest, quotes.

Madonna might direct a film depicting Kate and Prince William’s relationship.

Sarah Michelle Gellar’s two-year-old picked out her Golden Globes dress. Adorbs!

Some trouble between Madonna and Elton

Want to see Peeta with an Aussie accent?

Using orgasms as a sleep aid

George Clooney appreciates Michael Fassbender’s package

‘The Artist’ proves the silent film is back

Lana Del Rey sucks it up at SNL

Get him to stop being sooo needy

Pairing a print dress with a jean jacket

Are you ready to take the risk?

Stand up for yourself in 2012

The Situation can’t seem to stay out of trouble

Get to know Lana Del Rey

Teen heartthrobs of 1999

Are you ready for new Madonna?

What do guys think of feminism?

7 dude movies we secretly enjoy

How to style smoker flats

What do your relationships say about you?

Was Lady Gaga a nightmare to work for?

Even the silver fox gets a little nervous

Capitol Glam for Hunger Games

Whatever you do, don’t kiss like this

Lourdes channels her Material girl momma

Why you should try online dating

Get Lilo’s ferosh classy get-up

The WORST thing you can do the day after Christmas

Blame it on the booty call

We have a new appreciation for Bradley Cooper

Kris Humphries finally figures out how to make money off Kim

Another Gaga song for Britney?

Can the seasons be affecting your love life?

What old school computer game do you miss?

Madonna’s doing the halftime show at the Superbowl!

When did you stop believing in Santa?

25 Reasons we love Lizzie Olsen

Blast from the past: celebs when they were younger

Happy Movember, y’all!

Daniel Radcliffe’s favorite Harry Potter movie

Oscar Hosts over the years

Dealing with cold sores

We see London, we see France…

More women are seeing sex as a chore

The material girl gets personal

Getting Gucci emerald ankle strap sandals for less

Keep your knickers on ladies

Word on the street is that Madonna will be gracing us all with her biceps at the half time show of this year’s Super Bowl. Please contain your excitement.

Entertainment Weekly reports that this buzzed-about performance would coincide with her first single release from her upcoming album, due for release spring 2012.

I’ll just go out and say what we’re all thinking here (like always…sigh), much like the year 2012- Madonna at the half time show would be apocalyptic. Not only could she rip apart both teams with one of her hulk-hands but also there would be endless advertisements for her & Lourdes’ Material Girl brand: yikes!

If the visual I’ve just provided does not frighten you enough, please enjoy these 10 hypothetical horrors that will occur if this rumor comes to fruition:

initiating the gallery...