Fun things always happen on Watch What Happens Live. Kelly Clarkson was Andy Cohen’s guest last night, where she was a good sport as Andy made fun of From Justin to Kelly (anyone else remember that movie?) and played a round of Plead the Fifth, where she could only refuse to answer one of three questions. She gets candid (the wine helped) about whose Sound of Music performance was better, if she still thought Miley Cyrus was a “pitchy stripper,” and about her relationship with fellow American Idol alum Justin Guarini.
“We didn’t date during Idol, which everybody thought we were dating,” Kelly said. “We did date during…I feel like we weren’t dating during the movie. But I feel like maybe we did. We did date a little bit. I think any two people who are thrown together that much [would eventually date]. ‘Timeless,’ you put that song on From Justin to Kelly—you can’t fight it!”